The girls first title was a Division 1 co-championship with Jamestown in 1980 with an 11-1 record. After another co-championship with Jamestown in 1982 (9-1), Smith directed the Lady Trojans to their first perfect record (12-0) and outright title in 1984. It was that same year of 1982 that the boys won their first crown with a perfect 12-0 record.
The girls had more perfect seasons in 1984, 1986, 1987, 1989, 1996, 1997 and from 1999-2001 won 36 straight those years and 38 in a row dating back to 1998. During that same period, they captured eight straight league titles and from 1977-2001 had a record of 270-34.
Under Smith, the boys were a superb 307-70 from 1974-2001 with other unbeaten seasons besides 1982 being 1985, 1988-1992, 1998, 1998 and 2001. From 1988-1992, the Trojans rattled off 72 straight wins and extended that to 75 with three wins in 1993 before having that streak ended.
WKBW-TV named her Coach of the Year in 1987 and the next year she won a national high school coaching award from Scholastic Coach Magazine. In 1989, Smith received a century award for both boys and girls tennis from the New York State Coaches Association for having more than 100 wins. She was presented a service appreciation plaque for 15 years of leadership at the St. Bonaventure Tennis Camp in 1993. Then in 2001, she was given a plaque for the 300 Win Club as the boys coach.
Some of the outstanding players Smith has coached on the girls level have been Sandra Schwartz and Katy LeBaron, who are the first girls from Southwestern to ever advance to the state championships. They went back-to-back years as Section 6 doubles representatives in 1999 and 2000 and LeBaron finished her singles career in 2001 with a school league record of 47-1. For the boys, doubles Chris Christensen and Todd Anderson, doubles Jon Meyer and Eric Gressman, doubles Corey Schmitt and Jeff Hamilton, doubles Scott LeBaron and Ryan Calalesina along with Greg Livingston and Chris Post are among the top performers she has coached.
Tennis has been in her blood ever since she was youngster playing at the Allen Park courts. Individually, Smith has been a Chautauqua County champion many times in singles and has combined with Heidi Strickland for several doubles titles. From 1985-1993, Smith and Strickland were undefeated champions in The Post-Journal Classic women's doubles. That same duo also won or placed high in other tournaments throughout the years. Smith has served as the Division 1 boys and girls chairmanships and as Section 6 chairman she brought the girls championships to Chautauqua County and the Lakewood Family YMCA for the first time.