The Post-Journal

Act Of Kindness

NFL Commissioner Remembers Jamestown Icon With Special Gift

Jim McCusker enjoys a laugh at a March 2011 public screening of a rare film featuring the 1961-1962 Philadelphia Eagles on which Jim played left tackle.
In this file photo, Jim McCusker addresses a gathering at the Robert H. Jackson Center. P-J file photo by Scott Kindberg.

EDITOR’S NOTE: The following article first appeared in The Post-Journal on April 7, 2015.

A Jamestown establishment and the legacy of its beloved late proprietor have prompted an act of kindness by NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell.

For that, Mary McCusker, owner of The Pub on Main Street, is most thankful.

“If you are able to talk with him,” she told me last week, “tell him how moved I was. It meant a lot to me.”

The story has its origins when a package was delivered to The Pub three weeks ago, nearly a month after Mary’s husband Jim died at 78. In it was a Philadelphia Eagles No. 1 jersey with “McCusker” emblazoned on the back, in recognition of Jim’s seven years as an offensive lineman in the NFL, including four with the Eagles.

The package was addressed to “Pat and Scott McCusker,” although there is no Pat or Scott in the McCusker family.

Mary was unfazed, though.

“I automatically thought of (Pat Smeraldo, who is a bartender at The Pub),” she said. “I assumed it was him (who made it happen).”

After all, Smeraldo had spent months trying to procure an Eagles jersey from the team after a fire heavily damaged the bar in late 2013, but he said he hadn’t had any communication with the NFL franchise since last summer.

Mary also assumed “Scott” was yours truly, the author of a column that was published in The Post-Journal on Feb. 15, two days after Jim’s passing.

“I immediately thought of the article,” she said. “No doubt in my mind.”

In that piece, I suggested that a No. 1 Jamestown High School jersey — Jim was a first-team all-state player at his alma mater in the 1950s — be framed and hung at The Pub in recognition of how this community feels about its favorite son.

Well, thanks to the cooperation of JHS football coach Tom Langworthy, the Jock Shop, Jim Walton of I’ve Been Framed and the Chautauqua Sports Hall of Fame, that is scheduled to happen later this week.

But where does Goodell fit into all this?

Well, when Mary pulled the Eagles’ jersey out of the box (the return address read National Football League, Office of the Commissioner) two cards fell out — one for her and one for me.

Mary’s read:

“I’m sorry for the loss of your husband Jim. The article in The Post-Journal was a fitting tribute to an extraordinary man. I hope this jersey can hang in The Pub as a reminder of the special man he was.”

Mine read:

“I recently read your wonderful article on Jim McCusker. Thanks for sharing with all of us what a wonderful man he was as well as an NFL legend. I hope they can find a spot to hang this at The Pub.”

Both were signed, “Roger.”

“Someone either sent him the article or he subscribes to The Post-Journal online,” Mary said. “He had to read the whole thing. You know it involved the article, because of the No. 1 on the jersey.”

An email to the NFL commissioner’s office Monday morning seeking comment wasn’t immediately returned, but it’s clear that the framed No. 1 JHS jersey will soon have company on the walls of one of Jamestown’s favorite establishments.

Said Sam Lisciandro, Jim and Mary’s nephew and The Pub’s manager: “We should have those two (jerseys) next to each other (on the wall), because they’re related.”

Their connection was made possible because Goodell took the time to remember one of our own in a meaningful way.

From one Jamestown native to another.


The additional financial assistance of the community is critical to the success of the Chautauqua Sports Hall of Fame. We gratefully acknowledge these individuals and organizations for their generous support.