In 1983, entering his freshman year of high school, Creager’s parents paid tuition for him to attend Jamestown High School because his school district had no pool and offered no swimming program. At JHS, under the instruction of Bill Rollinger, his swimming talents were further developed. During his sophomore and junior years, he would rewrite the record book at JHS breaking 20 school and pool records in six events.
At JHS, he was an ECIC All-Star, five-time individual ECIC champion, multiple-time ECIC relay team champion and was a member of the 1985 ECIC title winning team. He was named the Post-Journal Swimmer of the Week nine times over a two-year stretch.
In Section VI championships, he was a four-time finalist who qualified for the state championship meet. He finished third in the 100-yard freestyle at the state meet as a sophomore and would final in two events the following year. He won a state title as a member of the 1985 Section VI team in 1985.
During his junior year Creager was recruited by one of the nation’s top high school swimming programs, Pine Crest School in Fort Lauderdale, FL. After considerable deliberation, Creager transferred from JHS to Pine Crest.
While at Pine Crest he would earn All-American status in three events: the 50-yard freestyle, the 100-yard freestyle, and as the anchor of the fastest high school 200-yard medley relay team in the United States in 1986. At the Florida state championships, he finished first in one event and second in two others as his Pine Crest team won the state championship. He was inducted into the Pine Crest School Athletic Hall of Fame in 1993.
Creager was actively recruited by colleges and ultimately accepted an athletic scholarship at Division 1 swimming powerhouse North Carolina State. He was a four-year varsity letterman at NC State where he was a finalist in Atlantic Coast Conference championships in both individual and relay events. He earned Academic All-American status in 1990 while studying pre-medical curriculum.
He received a medical degree from the University of North Carolina School of Medicine in 1995. Dr. Creager is currently President of Pathology Associates of Erie, Inc. and makes his home in Fairview, PA.